“Lean” is an especially timely concept for librarians now as demand for their services surge while budgets are being cut. That’s why we sat down with Neal-Schuman author John Huber to talk about his new book, Lean Library Management: Eleven Strategies for Reducing Costs and Improving Services.

John Huber at ALA New Orleans 2011
Huber’s background, with that of J. Huber and Associates–the management consulting firm he founded, is in helping organizations improve their customer service through improved process performance. He has assisted more than 100 organizations transform their operations.
Here, he answers a few questions about his book, Lean principles, and the response of the library community.
1. What is “Lean Manufacturing” and how did it come about?
Lean first and foremost engages and motivates the entire workforce to identify and eliminate all waste in a process. In the early 1980’s manufacturing and distribution companies (following the lead of the Toyota Motor Company) discovered that by eliminating waste in their processes they not only reduced cost and improved quality, they also dramatically reduced the lead-time required to deliver products and services to their customers. It was a game changer and a win-win strategy. In fact, it is no longer a question of whether a manufacturing company should deploy the concepts of Lean: it is a fundamental requirement of entry.
2. Why do you feel Lean Manufacturing has particularly relevance to libraries?
In 2001, I was invited by the Tulsa City/County Library to evaluate and improve the service capability of their delivery process (what I call the service delivery chain.) The ability of customers to request on-line a hold to be delivered to the branch of their choice had become hugely popular to the Tulsa community. Unfortunately the supporting delivery system (vans, tote boxes, pick list, in-transit slips and hold wrappers) was not able to support the ever-increasing volumes this popular service option had created. During our tour, I admit I was a bit apprehensive, after all what did I know about libraries? That changed very quickly, for I soon recognized many familiar things. I saw a manufacturing company (acquisitions, purchasing, technical services, processing); I saw a distribution company (receiving, warehousing, sorting, shipping, returns) and a retail organization (circulation desk, retail services, help desk). I discovered that behind the doors of every library, there was a complex manufacturing, distribution and retail organization. I realized at that moment that all my Lean skills, developed over a twenty-five years career, could be adapted to the library environment. In addition, I realized that Lean could transform the library world. As a result of this epiphany, I dedicated myself to assist libraries across North America transform their service and cost capabilities. The results have been dramatic:
• 50-75% reduction in new book delivery time.
• 50-75% reduction in holds delivery lead-time.
• 20-45% reduction in service delivery costs.
• 25-40% improvement in service days available.
• 25-90% reduction in injury related tasks.
• 25-90% reduction in internal book damage.

Huber at ALA New Orleans 2011
3. What is the main message you would like people to take away from Lean Library Management?
Lean is like a smooth flowing river, no twists and turns, no stagnant water, no dry banks, no hidden rocks, no white water and no flooding. The opposite of the Lean River is the Snake River. A river full of twists and turns, rocks that lie in wait to destroy your boat, dry banks that force you to carry your boat and flooding that forces you off the main flow of the river. The river, of course, is your service delivery chain, a series of processes that cross department boundaries. For example two primary service delivery chains are the New Book Service Delivery Chain and the Holds Service Delivery Chain. Every library I have worked with attempts to navigate the Snake River, which is a costly endeavor. To transform your library from the Snake River to the River Lean, you must engage your workforce to understand where these twists and turns, rocks, and dry banks occur and more importantly why. Lean is that strategy. Lean defines, measures, analyzes, improves and controls the performance of your service delivery chains.
Secondarily, libraries appear to be driven by two primary measurements: circulation and budgets. How many of you wake up in the morning and say: “I can’t wait to get to work today so I can increase our circulation and reduce our budgets”. Nearly every librarian and library staff member I have worked with are not motivated by circulation and budgets, but by servicing their customers. For me, Lean is not about cost reduction, Lean is about service improvement. It just happens to be a not very well known fact that as you improve service you reduce costs. My main message to libraries is that to survive in today’s competitive market (and yes, you have some tough competition) you must embrace Lean and you must embrace the service nature of your staff. If your staff embraces Lean to improve the service capability of your processes, you will reduce costs.
4. We heard from Dr. Annie Norman, State Librarian of Delaware, that she handed out your book “to rave reviews.” What kind of response has your book found in the library community?
Librarians and their staff are a highly intelligent and a well-educated group of people. It is no surprise to me that once explained, the concepts of Lean would be fully embraced by the library community. On a related note, I am frustrated that some city managers have come to a different conclusion. By their decisions to outsource library management responsibilities to ‘for-profit’ managers, they assume library leadership teams are incapable of adapting and responding to our current economic challenges. The facts and my experience argue just the opposite. Historically, libraries have been the very first to embrace change and to embrace new technology. For example, Libraries were one of the first to embrace the power and capability of the Internet, bar coding technology and now RFID. The idea that libraries cannot respond and adapt to new challenges is a false proposition.
However, prior to this book, it is true that most library managers and their staff had not been exposed or educated on how Lean concepts could streamline and improve their service delivery chains. Now that the book has been released and Libraries now understand the River Lean, it is just a matter of time that the concepts of Lean Library Management will be as common to libraries as every other new technology they have embraced.
Finally, I have been very pleased and humbled by how the library community has so fully embraced my book and the concepts of the Lean Library Management. As such, for all of you that have contributed to the ‘buzz’ that surrounds this book, I want to take this opportunity to thank you. Furthermore, I look forward to thanking you in person.
Learn more about Lean Library Management on the book’s webpage.
Comments Off